Best Pizza Places in Fayetteville, AR (2026): 15 Ranked by Reviews

Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville is the most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 1,401 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. Google describes it as funky, art-filled chain pizzeria featuring craft beer, calzones & creative stone-baked pizzas. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “One of the best mellow mushrooms I have gone to. Came through on our way to Missouri, and had a great experience. I can't remember who our server was but I think her name was Crystal. She was absolutely amazing.”

1460 E Augustine Ln, Fayetteville, AR 72703, USA

Geraldi's is the second-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 1,224 Google reviews and a 4.6-star average. Google describes it as casual Italian joint serving hot subs, pasta & classic pizzas, plus wine & craft beers on tap. It is moderately priced and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “If you’re looking for a quaint, low-key, casual Italian restaurant with INCREDIBLE food, this is the place! Every dish was absolutely delicious—fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care.”

20 S University Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Smokin' Oak Wood-Fired Pizza and Taproom is the third-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 1,129 Google reviews and a 4.8-star average. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 4-star reviewer wrote: “Smokin’ Oak Wood-Fired Pizza & Taproom was a good experience overall. The garlic bread was really good and definitely the highlight for me. The wood-fired pizza was decent—good crust and flavor.”

3959 N Steele Blvd #152, Fayetteville, AR 72703, USA

Grub's Bar & Grille is the fourth-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 1,064 Google reviews and a 4.3-star average. It is moderately priced and closed Monday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Grubs is a great place to go if you’re looking for somewhere to sit and eat with friends. I went a couple days ago and had an amazing experience. Everyone was so welcoming, and the service was excellent.”

220 N West Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Wood Stone Pizza - Mill District is the fifth-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 1,060 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. Google describes it as industrial-chic pizzeria turning out locally sourced pies & salads, plus craft brews & cocktails. It is inexpensive and closed Monday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “This is one of my favorite pizza places in Fayetteville! Don’t sleep on their appetizers though. They are amazing!”

557 S School Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Wood Stone Pizza Uptown is the sixth-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 1,052 Google reviews and a 4.4-star average. It is inexpensive and closed Monday, located in Fayetteville. One 4-star reviewer wrote: “Woodstone Pizza is pretty decent. It’s not the best pizza I’ve ever had, but it’s consistent, and sometimes that’s exactly what you need. It’s a super convenient option when you don’t want to overthink dinner.”

3619 Mall Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72703, USA

Gusano's Chicago Style Pizzeria is the seventh-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 1,050 Google reviews and a 4.4-star average. Google describes it as casual pizza joint with a sports-bar vibe dishing up Chicago-style pies plus weekday lunch specials. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “The atmosphere is great. Lots of people, trivia, music. The food was good but the pizza had a little too much sauce for me. Everything else was amazing though.”

1267 Steamboat Dr, Fayetteville, AR 72704, USA

U.S. Pizza Co Fayetteville is the eighth-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 727 Google reviews and a 4.1-star average. Google describes it as long-running pizzeria chain serving classic & creative pies, plus sandwiches, beer & wine. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 4-star reviewer wrote: “Restaurant was pretty busy, but not full. Elwood was very easy to work with. Our food was 🔥 burnt. I didn't complain 😌, but my friend did. It was replaced. One of the televisions 📺 was frozen picture.”

202 W Dickson St, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Marley's Pizzeria & Bar is the ninth-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 713 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. Google describes it as roomy hangout featuring a long bar with beer on tap & a patio for Chicago-style pizzas & sandwiches. It is inexpensive and closed Monday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Best pizza I've had in a long time!! Friendly staff as well. Hope to visit again!”

609 W Dickson St Ste 103, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Pizza Hut is the tenth-most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 663 Google reviews and a 3.8-star average. Google describes it as popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts. It is open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “A message to Pizza Hut Corporate, South School Pizza Hut is my go to living in south Fayetteville. Been ordering from here for years and yes some sometimes it hits better than other times.”

314 S School Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Tiny Tim's Pizza is the #11 most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 572 Google reviews and a 4.1-star average. Google describes it as simple pizzeria on the square offering thin-crust pies, subs & salads, along with craft beer. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Came in with my wife and two sons (toddler and 4 mo) during the lights on the square. Totally expected to be standing in line forever but Wes took us across the restaurant and got us seated very promptly.”

21 W Mountain St, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Fayetteville, AR is the #12 most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 547 Google reviews and a 4.3-star average. Google describes it as counter-serve chain for toasted subs topped with a wide array of ingredients, plus salads & pizza. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Amazing service!! I just placed an order under DoorDash and they completely scammed me and refused to refund me!! Picklemans without thinking twice invited me down to remake my sandwhiches!”

410 W Dickson St, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Domino's Pizza is the #13 most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 543 Google reviews and a 4.1-star average. Google describes it as delivery, carryout & dine-in chain offering a wide range of pizzas, plus a variety of other dishes & sides. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville.

1113 Garland Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72703, USA

Bocca Italian eatery & pizzeria is the #14 most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 540 Google reviews and a 4.2-star average. Google describes it as stylish Italian spot with an open kitchen serving wood-fired pizza & housemade pasta with full bar. It is moderately priced and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville.

2036 N College Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72703, USA

Morano's Bar & Grill is the #15 most-reviewed pizza place in Fayetteville, with 512 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. It is moderately priced and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 4-star reviewer wrote: “Great burger. Husband liked it. Hand cut fries are the best. Nachos are good but VERY little meat or cheese below that top layer. They are around $12-13 . Mushrooms are decent and ranch is too.”

2179 M.L.K. Jr Blvd, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA