Best Bakeries in Fayetteville, AR (2026): 15 Ranked by Reviews

Rick's Bakery is the most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 1,479 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. Google describes it as bustling venue for a wide variety of baked goods & pastries, plus cafe bites & outdoor seating. It is moderately priced and closed Sunday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “I reached out to Rick’s Bakery to get a custom cake made for my wife’s birthday. They promptly responded and I gave them the idea I had and they diligently and thoughtfully walked me through the process.”

1220 N College Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72703, USA

Little Bread Company is the second-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 816 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. Google describes it as sandwiches, espresso drinks & housemade pastries in a laid-back space with a welcoming patio. It is moderately priced and closed Monday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “As tourists, Little Bread Company was one of the best surprises we found in Fayetteville. We had already noticed a really good vibe around the city, and places like this confirmed it.”

116 N Block Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Stone Mill Bread is the third-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 599 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. It is inexpensive and closed Sunday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “It's clean and neat and simply decorated. The bathrooms are very nice. I got the BALT on spinach feta bread- it was amazing. There was plenty of bacon and the veggies were fresh. The bread was warm and delicious.”

2600 N Gregg Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72703, USA

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Fayetteville, AR is the fourth-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 547 Google reviews and a 4.3-star average. Google describes it as counter-serve chain for toasted subs topped with a wide array of ingredients, plus salads & pizza. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Amazing service!! I just placed an order under DoorDash and they completely scammed me and refused to refund me!! Picklemans without thinking twice invited me down to remake my sandwhiches!”

410 W Dickson St, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Cronuts Donuts is the fifth-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 507 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. Google describes it as chain with a variety of yeast, cake & filled donuts, plus kolaches, espresso drinks & smoothies. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Great selection of donuts! They were delicious too. Donut holes and blueberry filled donut were our favorites. Highly recommend as a great stop for donuts!”

1151 M.L.K. Jr Blvd, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Nellie B's Bakery is the sixth-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 357 Google reviews and a 4.9-star average. Google describes it as family-run bakery featuring morning pastries, mini quiches, cakes & other sweets. It is inexpensive and closed Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Sunday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “This was such a cute shop. It had a nice atmosphere, kid friendly, and gluten free friendly! We tried at least 5 different menu items and all were amazing flavor!”

2129 N Center St, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Golden Kolache Bakery is the seventh-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 342 Google reviews and a 4.9-star average. It is inexpensive and closed Monday and Sunday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “The best pastries ive ever had, the spinach and artichoke kolaches are my go to. The staff are always so friendly as well.”

3327 W Wedington Dr, Fayetteville, AR 72704, USA

Insomnia Cookies is the eighth-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 287 Google reviews and a 3.9-star average. Google describes it as bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries. It is open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 4-star reviewer wrote: “The cookies were warm and decent tasting but not the best cookie I’ve ever had. We got chocolate chip and it had just the right amount of crunch around the edges and the softness was on point but I think it would’ve…”

609 W Dickson St Ste 202, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Rymolene's Pies is the ninth-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 275 Google reviews and a 4.7-star average. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “This place is the best! The atmosphere is soooo cozy and the key lime pie is so so good (they use authentic juice from Key West) and the pumpkin is one of the bests (her great grandmothers recipe).”

955 N Shiloh Dr, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

The Pink Elephant Social House is the tenth-most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 176 Google reviews and a 4.9-star average. It is closed Monday and Sunday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Ordered the 15-person charcuterie board to share with my coworkers for a celebration.”

3 E Mountain St, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Alchemy Macarons is the #11 most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 153 Google reviews and a 4.9-star average. It is closed Sunday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Out shopping? Need a snack? Need something sweet and flavorful? This is the place to stop and visit! Good service, clean environment, and plenty of flavors to choose from ... not to mention the option to have some tea!”

112 W Center St #130, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Benny’s Bagels is the #12 most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 141 Google reviews and a 4.2-star average. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Benny’s Bagels – Fayetteville, Arkansas I’ve had several students from the University of Arkansas tell me for a while now that I needed to try Benny’s Bagels, so this morning I finally made the stop.”

826 N Leverett Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

baked by kori is the #13 most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 44 Google reviews and a 4.4-star average. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “They had coloring books and markers for the kids which was awesome. The staff were friendly and service was fast, First off $4 for a single cookie is high in my mind, but their flavors are on point for a great cookie.”

644 W Dickson St #114, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Chewk's Cookies Fayetteville is the #14 most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 30 Google reviews and a 5.0-star average. It is inexpensive and closed Monday and Sunday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Chewks. I don’t know where to begin. You need a cookie? They got you. You need a friend? They got you. The buttery soft chocolate chip heaven graced my tastebuds and I experienced the eighth wonder of the world.”

205 W Dickson St, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA

Dempsey Bakery is the #15 most-reviewed bakery in Fayetteville, with 26 Google reviews and a 4.6-star average. It is moderately priced and closed Sunday, located in Fayetteville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “WOW! Just had a deeelicious GLUTEN FREE Bacon Cheddar Danish! I was greeted by a friendly, knowledge host-- maybe the owner. EVERYTHING in the place is Gluten free (!)And there are Dairy Free and Egg Free options.”

481 S School Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA