1
Goodwill Store and Donation Center
Siloam Springs4.1(332 Google reviews)
Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, furniture, housewares & more. Open seven days a week.
1001 S Mt Olive St, Siloam Springs, AR 72761, USA
Best Thrift Stores in Siloam Springs, Arkansas
As of November 2026, Goodwill Store and Donation Center is the most-reviewed thrift store in Siloam Springs with 332 Google reviews and a 4.1-star average, ranking #8 across all of Northwest Arkansas. 5 thrift stores with a Siloam Springs address made the cut, out of 30 ranked region-wide.
Updated November 1, 2026 · How we rank
| # | Business | City | Rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goodwill Store and Donation Center | Siloam Springs | 4.1 | 332 |
| 2 | Potter's House Thrift | Siloam Springs | 4.1 | 262 |
| 3 | Magnolia Trading Post, Llc | Siloam Springs | 5.0 | 221 |
| 4 | Manna Center Inc. | Siloam Springs | 4.6 | 186 |
| 5 | Beautiful Lives Thrift Boutique Siloam Springs | Siloam Springs | 4.8 | 50 |
2
Potter's House Thrift
Siloam Springs4.1(262 Google reviews)
Open seven days a week.
2101 US-412 East, Siloam Springs, AR 72761, USA
3
Magnolia Trading Post, Llc
Siloam Springs5.0(221 Google reviews)
Closed Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.
1004 S Mt Olive St K, Siloam Springs, AR 72761, USA
4
Manna Center Inc.
Siloam Springs4.6(186 Google reviews)
Closed Sunday.
670 Heritage Ct, Siloam Springs, AR 72761, USA
5
Beautiful Lives Thrift Boutique Siloam Springs
Siloam Springs4.8(50 Google reviews)
Closed Sunday.
506 E Main St, Siloam Springs, AR 72761, USA
How we rank
We search Google for every thrift store in Northwest Arkansas, keep open businesses with at least 5 reviews whose Google listing matches the category, then rank those with a Siloam Springs address by Google review count. Businesses in neighboring cities often serve Siloam Springs too; the region-wide list covers them. Full methodology.
Questions
- Who is the most-reviewed thrift store in Siloam Springs?
- Goodwill Store and Donation Center has the most Google reviews of any thrift store in Siloam Springs, with 332 reviews and a 4.1-star average as of our last check.
- Which thrift store in Siloam Springs has the highest rating?
- Among thrift stores with at least 50 reviews, Magnolia Trading Post, Llc has the highest average at 5.0 stars across 221 reviews.
- How is this ranking calculated?
- We pull every thrift store Google lists in Northwest Arkansas, drop any with fewer than 5 reviews or marked closed, and rank the rest by total Google review count, with rating as the tiebreaker. This list covers 1,051 reviews. No business can pay to be ranked.