1
Pedaler's Pub
Bentonville$4.4(2,576 Google reviews)
Industrial-chic tavern with an outdoor patio & an Italian/American menu focused on wood-fired pizza. Closed Monday.
500 S Main St, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
Best Pizza Places in Bentonville, Arkansas
As of November 2026, Pedaler's Pub is the most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville with 2,576 Google reviews and a 4.4-star average, ranking #1 across all of Northwest Arkansas. 10 pizza places with a Bentonville address made the cut, out of 30 ranked region-wide.
Updated November 1, 2026 · How we rank
| # | Business | City | Rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Pedaler's Pub$ | Bentonville | 4.4 | 2,576 |
| 2 | Gusano's Pizzeria$ | Bentonville | 4.4 | 1,747 |
| 3 | Oven & Tap$$ | Bentonville | 3.9 | 1,423 |
| 4 | Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza$ | Bentonville | 4.3 | 926 |
| 5 | Joe's Italian Grill with Indian Kitchen$$ | Bentonville | 3.9 | 670 |
| 6 | Marco's Pizza$ | Bentonville | 4.1 | 433 |
| 7 | Papa Johns Pizza$ | Bentonville | 3.4 | 233 |
| 8 | Simple Simon's Pizza$ | Bentonville | 4.8 | 192 |
| 9 | Priato Pizzeria$$ | Bentonville | 4.1 | 147 |
| 10 | Pizza Lottie’s$$ | Bentonville | 4.5 | 121 |
2
Gusano's Pizzeria
Bentonville$4.4(1,747 Google reviews)
Casual pizza joint with a sports-bar vibe dishing up Chicago-style pies plus weekday lunch specials. Open seven days a week.
2905 S Walton Blvd #9, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
3
Oven & Tap
Bentonville$$3.9(1,423 Google reviews)
Relaxed place for wood-fired pizzas, sandwiches & Southern-inspired fare, plus a bar & craft beer. Closed Monday.
215 S Main St #3, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
4
Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza
Bentonville$4.3(926 Google reviews)
Relaxed pizzeria chain serving NY-style hand-tossed pies, plus pasta & sandwiches. Open seven days a week.
700 SE Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
5
Joe's Italian Grill with Indian Kitchen
Bentonville$$3.9(670 Google reviews)
Pizza, pasta & other Italian fare in a casual, upbeat space with sports memorabilia & lots of TVs. Closed Tuesday.
3404 SE Macy Rd Ste 14, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
6
Marco's Pizza
Bentonville$4.1(433 Google reviews)
Counter-serve chain serving up a menu of specialty or custom pizzas for takeout or delivery. Open seven days a week.
2502 SW 14th St #4, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
7
Papa Johns Pizza
Bentonville$3.4(233 Google reviews)
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts. Open seven days a week.
231 N Walton Blvd #5, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
8
Simple Simon's Pizza
Bentonville$4.8(192 Google reviews)
Classic & creative pizzas, subs & calzones fill the menu at this easygoing Italian chain. Open seven days a week.
1140 N Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
9
Priato Pizzeria
Bentonville$$4.1(147 Google reviews)
Open seven days a week.
1004 SE 5th St, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
10
Pizza Lottie’s
Bentonville$$4.5(121 Google reviews)
Closed Monday.
1401 NE John Deshields Blvd #135, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA
How we rank
We search Google for every pizza place in Northwest Arkansas, keep open businesses with at least 5 reviews whose Google listing matches the category, then rank those with a Bentonville address by Google review count. Businesses in neighboring cities often serve Bentonville too; the region-wide list covers them. Full methodology.
Questions
- Who is the most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville?
- Pedaler's Pub has the most Google reviews of any pizza place in Bentonville, with 2,576 reviews and a 4.4-star average as of our last check.
- Which pizza place in Bentonville has the highest rating?
- Among pizza places with at least 50 reviews, Simple Simon's Pizza has the highest average at 4.8 stars across 192 reviews.
- How expensive are the top pizza places in Bentonville?
- Of the 10 pizza places with a Google price level, 6 inexpensive, 4 moderately priced. Price levels are Google's four-tier scale.
- How is this ranking calculated?
- We pull every pizza place Google lists in Northwest Arkansas, drop any with fewer than 5 reviews or marked closed, and rank the rest by total Google review count, with rating as the tiebreaker. This list covers 8,468 reviews. No business can pay to be ranked.