Best Pizza Places in Bentonville, AR (2026): 16 Ranked by Reviews

Pedaler's Pub is the most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 2,558 Google reviews and a 4.4-star average. Google describes it as industrial-chic tavern with an outdoor patio & an Italian/American menu focused on wood-fired pizza. It is inexpensive and closed Monday, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Great place. They were open on the 4th of July so my family we had a group of us were able to go try it. Pizza was great and some of my family got the loaded fries and said they were good.”

500 S Main St, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Tavola Trattoria is the second-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 2,242 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. Google describes it as casual bistro offering family-style Italian dining with a long wine list in a trendy, modern space. It is moderately priced and open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “I truly loved this place because of how pleasant the people were, and that's before I noticed how hard they worked on the little things.”

108 SE A St, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Gusano's Pizzeria is the third-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 1,730 Google reviews and a 4.4-star average. Google describes it as casual pizza joint with a sports-bar vibe dishing up Chicago-style pies plus weekday lunch specials. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “We are new to the area and considering a job transfer to the area for my employer. We were told by coworker’s that we had to try Gusanos Pizza.”

2905 S Walton Blvd #9, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Oven & Tap is the fourth-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 1,414 Google reviews and a 3.9-star average. Google describes it as relaxed place for wood-fired pizzas, sandwiches & Southern-inspired fare, plus a bar & craft beer. It is moderately priced and closed Monday, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Being a bit of a pizza snob. My single biggest pet peeve is putting the pizza in the oven WITH the basil on the pie. You burn the flavor of the fresh basil right out.”

215 S Main St #3, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza is the fifth-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 921 Google reviews and a 4.2-star average. Google describes it as relaxed pizzeria chain serving NY-style hand-tossed pies, plus pasta & sandwiches. It is open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Ms. Rachel is an excellent server and was outgoing, very pleasant, and attentive. It was our first time to Johnny Brusco’s and I think it’s my favorite pizza in the area or a top contender.”

700 SE Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Domino's Pizza is the sixth-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 762 Google reviews and a 3.9-star average. Google describes it as delivery, carryout & dine-in chain offering a wide range of pizzas, plus a variety of other dishes & sides. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 4-star reviewer wrote: “Quality food for a great family meal. $7.99 for a 3 topping large pizza. That's pretty impressive. I like the thin crust and the hand tossed. I prefer the garlic or alfredo base over the tomato sauce.”

2800 SW 14th St 2 Ste 2, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Mezzaluna Pasteria & Mozzarella Bar is the seventh-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 402 Google reviews and a 4.3-star average. It is moderately priced and closed Monday and Sunday, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “We had a birthday to celebrate and came back to Mezzaluna to see what new things were on the menu. Service was fabulous, with suggestions for the menu and wine selection, Thanks Faith!”

215 NW A St Ste 140, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Papa Johns Pizza is the eighth-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 231 Google reviews and a 3.4-star average. Google describes it as pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts. It is open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “The food was absolutely incredible. The delivery driver was very kind! Some of the best chain pizza I’ve had in a hot minute.”

231 N Walton Blvd Ste 5, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Parlay on 8th is the ninth-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 209 Google reviews and a 4.5-star average. It is moderately priced and open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 4-star reviewer wrote: “We really enjoyed our visit and would definitely come back — the food was overall amazing. The fried items were perfectly done, and the flavors were on point.”

801 SE 8th St #21, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Simple Simon's Pizza is the tenth-most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 191 Google reviews and a 4.8-star average. Google describes it as classic & creative pizzas, subs & calzones fill the menu at this easygoing Italian chain. It is inexpensive and open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Overall great pizza. We had the pepperoni and cheese for this review. Right amount of sauce and cheese with good tasting ingredients and not much grease at all.”

1140 N Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Danger Dave's is the #11 most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 170 Google reviews and a 4.3-star average. It is moderately priced and closed Sunday, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Went in on a Saturday afternoon in spring, obviously riding our bikes around, park up, cocktails, outside seating under the tree, awesome sandwiches, we order the Jan Jam and it was awesome!”

310 S Main St, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Priato Pizzeria is the #12 most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 147 Google reviews and a 4.1-star average. It is moderately priced and open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “came here for the first time to meet a new friend during the summer last year. i brought leftovers to my husband and we've been wanting to come back ever since! they relocated to a new location in bentonville.”

1004 SE 5th St, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Pizza Lottie’s is the #13 most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 113 Google reviews and a 4.3-star average. It is moderately priced and closed Monday, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “I am a huge food person. I have worked in the food industry for a few years before finding my calling. Let me tell you, this place was impressive.”

1401 NE John Deshields Blvd #135, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Onyx at The Preserve is the #14 most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 113 Google reviews and a 4.3-star average. It is moderately priced and open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 4-star reviewer wrote: “Onyx is one of the most unique restaurants I've visited in Bentonville. The architecture is absolutely incredible, and the way the space is designed creates a really interesting atmosphere that sets it apart from just…”

1101 Excellence Dr, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

TABLE AU CENTRE is the #15 most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 72 Google reviews and a 4.4-star average. It is moderately priced and open seven days a week, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Everything was amazing that we got for dinner. Bread came out before dinner. Server, Food, Atmosphere awesome. Definitely try it out sometime. The prices were all amazing and reasonable.”

909 SE J St, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA

Barley & Vine is the #16 most-reviewed pizza place in Bentonville, with 67 Google reviews and a 4.4-star average. It is inexpensive and closed Monday, located in Bentonville. One 5-star reviewer wrote: “Listen. Just go here. It’s an awesome new place just off the square where you can enjoy one of over 25 beers on tap and even more bottled.”

113 W Central Ave #103, Bentonville, AR 72712, USA